I was in Buckhead today in a pizza kinda mood, so I decided to give Nancy's Pizza a second chance. Overall, my experience was more upbeat than my previous report.
I ordered an individual pizza with pepperoni and mushroom. Even though I probably shouldn't have eaten quite that much, I wanted to order a fresh pizza to give poor Nancy a chance. This was a thin crust pizza, not the true Chicago-style thick crust. The crust has that slightly Bisquicky taste that I also associate with Pizzeria Uno; it must be a Chicago thing. I don't mind it and I even sort of like it, but it's very different from the New York style of pizza dough. I was a little disappointed with the cheese, which didn't contain enough mozarella for my taste. But overall, it was a pretty good pizza. It has nothing to be ashamed of.